Where: 99¢ Pizza
143 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018

Why: Great location means there is always a steady flow of customers, no matter what time of day, ensuring freshness.

What: Beats most $3 slices in the city because of the wonderful balance of dough and cheese, without any hint of overbearing tomato sauce (looking at you, Two Bros).. Two slices and a Coke for $2.75 is forever a satisfying purchase. This is 2018, after all.